School Transport Policy
Request 101004076491
I request copies of the school transport policy, and any associated guidance or procedures, that were in force immediately before Moray Council’s revised school transport policy was approved by Full Council on 24 September 2025.
In particular, I request the following:
1. Previous policy wording: A complete copy of the school transport policy in force immediately before the September 2025 changes, including its publication date, version number and any relevant appendices and the date it was taken offline.
2. Police Scotland review provision: The exact wording of any provision stating that parents or carers who disagreed with the Council’s assessment of a walking route as safe could contact Police Scotland for a review, and that the Council would accept or act upon the police’s decision.
3. Revised policy: A copy of the revised policy approved on 24 September 2025, including the version published online and the date it was first made available to the public online.
4. Changes between versions: Any document, amendment schedule, tracked-change version or other record identifying the changes made to the policy, particularly any changes relating to:
Police Scotland’s involvement in reviewing disputed walking routes;
who has authority to determine whether a walking route is safe;
the process for parents or carers to challenge a route-safety decision; and
any independent review or appeal mechanism.
5. Reasons for removing the provision: Any recorded information explaining why the previous provision concerning Police Scotland reviews was removed or amended, including relevant committee reports, policy-development documents, consultation responses, meeting minutes or decision records.
6. Alternative safeguards: Any policy or procedural documents explaining what review, appeal or independent scrutiny is available under the revised policy where parents or carers disagree with a Council officer’s assessment that a walking route is safe.
7. Implementation and communication: Any guidance or instructions issued to relevant Council officers about the change to the review process and how parents should raise or challenge concerns about the safety of a walking route.
I am particularly interested in the policy provisions concerning the assessment of safe walking routes for children travelling to and from school.
Response 16-Nov-2026
School Transport Policy
1. Information not specifically held, as such Section 25 of the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 (FOISA) is applicable. The policy prior to September 2025 is not documented policy.
In a budget report to Full Council on 14 February 2018 it notes that the Council currently provides school transport to entitled pupils attending their zoned school for all pupils, primary and secondary, where their zoned school is more than 2 miles from their home address, or where there is not a safe walking route to the school. A decision was made at this point to increase the distance to 3 miles for pupils at Elgin Academy and Elgin High School as a budget saving.
2. Information not specifically held, as such Section 25 of the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 (FOISA) is applicable.
Anecdotally it is known by officers that historically the Police had some resources available to support the Council where a second opinion was sought as the suitability of an assessed walking route. This was referenced on the School Transport pages of our website until the beginning of March 2026 where it was amended to reflect that this support is not something that the Police can routinely provide. To clarify it is not part of the remit of the Police to review our assessments, either on a practical basis or as part of a statutory responsibility.
The wording on our website was amended on 10th March 2026 at the same time as we made clarifications on the changes to distances for eligibility for School Transport.
Previous wording: If an issue of road safety is identified for a family living closer than two miles to the zoned school, then we may ask the Police to undertake a safety assessment on the journey involved. We will abide by the decision, and an assessment by the Police indicating if there are hazards present in the journey will result in transport being provided, subject to completing the online application form.
Current wording: If an issue of road safety is identified for a family living closer than two miles to the zoned primary school or three miles from the zoned secondary school, then we may ask a traffic engineer to undertake a safety assessment on the journey involved. Depending on the result of the assessment, should hazards be identified in the journey then we will direct the family to apply online for an application to school transport, resulting in transport being provided.
3. The Council’s School Transport Policy is set out through decisions taken at Full Council from two committee reports. These were published just prior to the dates of the committee and are available online.
24th September 2025
Home to School Transport Policy
26th June 2025
School Transport Policy and Implementation
Note: The document published on our website in September is operational guidance that was drafted following a recognition that the team undertaking the role of assessments, whilst well versed in the process, did not have any written guidance to support the process, and the process was unclear to the public. This document was uploaded to our website on 26th June 2026.
The summary information on our webpages was edited as follows on 10 March 2026:
Previous wording: Free home to school transport is provided to pupils who reside in excess of two miles from the zoned school. The exception to this is to Elgin Secondary Schools where the excess distance will be the statutory 3 miles as decided by Council Committee. It is accepted that pupils may walk, accompanied by a resonsible adult, up to two miles to the nearest school transport pick up point. Free transport will not be provided to parents who choose to enrol their children at an out of zone school.
Current wording: Free home to school transport is provided to pupils who reside in excess of two miles from the zoned school for primary and three miles from the zoned school for secondary. It is accepted that pupils may walk, accompanied by a responsible adult, up to two miles for primary pupils and three miles for secondary pupils to the nearest school transport pick up point. Free transport will not be provided to parents who choose to enrol their children at an out of zone school.
4. Changes between versions: Any document, amendment schedule, tracked-change version or other record identifying the changes made to the policy, particularly any changes relating to:
a) Information not held, as such Section 25 of the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 (FOISA) is applicable.
b) Council officers following the agreed guidance determine whether a walking route is safe. Please see here an extract of an email from the Head of Operations & Environment sent to a member of the public which also holds this information:
“Once councillors have set a policy position, complaints or queries around the application of that policy and its operation should be handled by officers in the appropriate council service. The council in its Scheme of Delegation places the responsibility for the provision of a school transport service in accordance with the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 with me as Head of Operations and Environment. Further we have clarified in setting the revised school transport policy in September 2025 that any dis-satisfaction with a walking route should be raised via the Public Transport Unit, firstly for review by the Service Manager Transportation and secondly (where necessary) by the Head of Operations and Environment.”
c) Please see below an extract from an email from the Head of Operations and Environment which details the process.
“Once councillors have set a policy position, complaints or queries around the application of that policy and its operation should be handled by officers in the appropriate council service. The council in its Scheme of Delegation places the responsibility for the provision of a school transport service in accordance with the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 with me as Head of Operations and Environment. Further we have clarified in setting the revised school transport policy in September 2025 that any dis-satisfaction with a walking route should be raised via the Public Transport Unit, firstly for review by the Service Manager Transportation and secondly (where necessary) by the Head of Operations and Environment.”
This is also documented in the guidance and provided below for ease of reference :
6.0 Reviewing an Assessment Decision
6.1 There may be instances where the findings of an assessment are disputed by a
parent/carer. The parent/carer may request a copy of the assessment which will then
be issued to them. The issue of the assessment will be undertaken in the timescales
appropriate to a front-line complaint, currently 5 days. The parent/carer should respond
within 20 working days, setting out their concerns and objections to decision reached in
the assessment.
6.2 Any representation received from the parent/carer will be reviewed by the
Service Manager Transportation in conjunction with the members of the Public
Transport Unit. The decision of Service Manager Transportation will be the final
outcome of the process unless they have a material concern on the original decision, in
which case the Head of Service will be consulted to agree an outcome. A final decision
involving all parties referred to should be issued within 20 working days.
d) Please see below an extract from an email from the Head of Operations and Environment which details the process.
“Once councillors have set a policy position, complaints or queries around the application of that policy and its operation should be handled by officers in the appropriate council service. The council in its Scheme of Delegation places the responsibility for the provision of a school transport service in accordance with the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 with me as Head of Operations and Environment. Further we have clarified in setting the revised school transport policy in September 2025 that any dis-satisfaction with a walking route should be raised via the Public Transport Unit, firstly for review by the Service Manager Transportation and secondly (where necessary) by the Head of Operations and Environment.”
There is no independent review or appeal mechanism unless there is an error in application of the Council’s policy which is not rectified by the Council through the complaints process, whereby the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman may review.
5. Information not held, as such Section 25 of the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 (FOISA) is applicable.
6. As Q4, parts C and D.
This is documented in the guidance and provided below for ease of reference :
6.0 Reviewing an Assessment Decision
6.1 There may be instances where the findings of an assessment are disputed by a
parent/carer. The parent/carer may request a copy of the assessment which will then
be issued to them. The issue of the assessment will be undertaken in the timescales
appropriate to a front-line complaint, currently 5 days. The parent/carer should respond
within 20 working days, setting out their concerns and objections to decision reached in
the assessment.
6.2 Any representation received from the parent/carer will be reviewed by the
Service Manager Transportation in conjunction with the members of the Public
Transport Unit. The decision of Service Manager Transportation will be the final
outcome of the process unless they have a material concern on the original decision, in
which case the Head of Service will be consulted to agree an outcome. A final decision
involving all parties referred to should be issued within 20 working days.
7. Information not held, as such Section 25 of the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 (FOISA) is applicable. When the operational guidance was issued on our website, it was also provided to officers that undertake these assessments.